Olympus-OM
[Top] [All Lists]

[OM] Re: E-1 bits & parts advice

Subject: [OM] Re: E-1 bits & parts advice
From: Philippe Dambournet <zuikomane@xxxxxxx>
Date: Sun, 6 Jan 2008 00:27:28 -0600
Thank you, Moose -- so, in a nutshell, if I'm careful enough to avoid  
anything touching the front element (rely on the hood and cap) and I  
learn to clean it safely, I'm probably better off using filters only  
as needed? Is that your practice, BTW?

Phil

On Jan 05, 2008, at 20:31, Listar wrote:

> You appear to be operating under a misunderstanding. All filters  
> degrade
> the image. Most will not do so to an extent that you will notice, but
> the simple act of passing the light through two parallel, flat,
> air/glass surfaces has an optical effect, separate from the issue of
> coatings. You are in effect adding an unnecessary element to the  
> lens so
> much time and effort was spent in designing.
>
> If you find it necessary to have a filter on the lens, there is no
> excuse with digital to avoid taking identical shots with and  
> without the
> filter at a few different focal lengths and apertures and checking  
> them
> carefully against each other. Some filters have defects that may
> seriously degrade image quality but are not noticeable to the eye.
> According to Gary Reese's tests, this can happen even with the top  
> brands.
>
> A few years ago, we had a fellow on the list who whined on and on  
> about
> the poor image quality of one of his Zuiko lenses. We proposed all  
> sorts
> of possibilities until one day the light dawned and I suggested if he
> had a filter on it (which he had never mentioned) that he should  
> remove
> it. Problem solved.
>
> With digital, the plot thickens. The front surfaces of sensors and the
> filters in front of them are very flat and shiny, much more so than
> film. This occasionally causes problems with lenses designed for film
> with element surfaces that are relatively flat. Lenses designed for
> digital try to avoid that and use even stronger AR coatings than  
> before.
> However, a filter has two perfectly flat surfaces, and even with those
> specially coated for digital, there are occasional odd effects in  
> night
> shots. I've seen a few examples where weird looking things in images
> turn out to be a result of using filters.
>
> So sure, if you are clumsy or paranoid, use a filter. But test it when
> you get it and be aware it can cause odd image effects.
>
> Moose


==============================================
List usage info:     http://www.zuikoholic.com
List nannies:        olympusadmin@xxxxxxxxxx
==============================================

<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>
Sponsored by Tako
Impressum | Datenschutz